- Research article
- Open Access
Physico-chemical characterisation and biological evaluation of 188-Rhenium colloids for radiosynovectomy
BMC Nuclear Medicine volume 2, Article number: 1 (2002)
Radiosynovectomy is a type of radiotherapy used to relieve pain and inflammation from rheumatoid arthritis. In this study, 188-Rhenium (188Re) colloids were characterized by physical and biological methodologies. This was used to assess which parameters of the kit formulation would be the basis in the development of a more effective radiopharmaceutical for synovectomy. Intraarticular injection in knees of rabbits assessed cavity leakage of activity.
The physical characteristics of tin (Sn) and sulphur (S) colloids were determined to assess the formulation with suitable properties. Particles were grouped in three ranges for analyzing their distribution according to their number, volume and surface. The ideal particle size range was considered to be from 2 to 10 microns. Membrane filtration and laser diffraction characterization methodologies were used.
While membrane filtration could give misleading data, laser diffraction proportions more reliable results. The Sn colloid showed a better distribution of particle volume and surface than S colloid, in the 2 to 10 microns range. The 188Re-Sn colloid was obtained with a radiochemical purity higher than 95% after 30 minutes of autoclaving. While Sn colloid kit stability was verified for 60 days, the 188Re-Sn preparation was stable in the first 24 hrs. No significant intrabatch variability (n = 3) was detected. Biodistribution and scintigraphic studies in rabbits after intraarticular injection showed relevant activity only in knee, being 90% at 48 hours.
The 188Re-Sn colloid is easy to prepare, is stable for 24 hours and shows minimal cavity leakage after intraarticular injection into rabbit knees, suggesting this radiotherapeutical agent has suitable physical properties for evaluation for joint treatment in humans.
Radiosynovectomy is a radiotherapy, which has been used for more than 40 years to relieve pain and inflammation from rheumatoid arthritis (RA). It was developed as an alternative to surgical synovectomy [1–3]. The procedure consists in the injection of a beta-emitting radionuclide into the joint capsule [4, 5], where it remains in contact with the synovial membrane or synovium. The intraarticular-administered radiopharmaceutical is then phagocyted by the lining cells, which are on the synovial surface. While the radionuclide is decaying the absorbed dose is being given to the synovium.
188Rhenium is an attractive radionuclide for radiosynovectomy because of its suitable chemistry, t1/2 = 16.9 hours and average beta energy of 776 keV (Emax = 2.11 MeV, 79%). These properties enable knee treatment due to its maximal tissue penetration of 11 mm, and its mean range of 3.8 mm [6, 8]. 188Re decays to the stable 188Os, with a gamma ray emission of 155 KeV (15%) that is suitable for image acquisition. This fact allows target uptake evaluation, as well as the estimation of the absorbed radiation dose. Besides this, rhenium-188 is readily available on routine bases from the tungsten-188/rhenium-188 generator system [9, 10], which has a useful shelf-life of several months.
The ideal radiopharmaceutical radiolabeled with 188Re for radiosynovectomy should meet the following requirements:
a) 188Rhenium should be attached to a particle that is sufficiently small to be phagocytized, but not so small that it might leak from the joint before being phagocytized; the appropriate size range is usually considered to be from 2 to 10 microns;
b) the binding between the radionuclide and the particle should be irreversible throughout the course of the radiotherapy, which, in turn, is determined by the physical half-life of the radionuclide;
c) the radiolabeled particles should be distributed homogeneously in the joint without initiating an inflammatory response.
Taking into account a previous study , which showed that colloidal preparations are the ones that best fulfil these requirements, the 188Re-Sn and 188 Re-S colloids were prepared.
The radiocolloid preparations were studied by two methodologies – laser diffraction and membrane filtration – in order to analyze which physical parameters were more relevant to accomplish the characteristics described above.
In this study, the 188Re colloids were characterized by physical and biological methodologies to assess which parameters of the kit formulation enable to achieve a better radiopharmaceutical for synovectomy. The 188Re-Sn colloid was evaluated in preliminary studies by evaluating capsule leakage by gamma camera imaging after intraarticular administration in rabbit knees.
Colloids kit composition
The 188Re-Sn colloid was prepared according to the following formulation, modified from that previously reported 
10 mg SnCl2.2H2O
0.5 mL HCl 0.1 N
2 mg ascorbic acid
One per cent w/w Tween 80® in experiments where indicated
The 188Re-S colloid kit was prepared with the following composition :
40 mg Na2S2O3
4.8 mg EDTA disodium salt
0.8 mg KReO4 carrier
1.5 mL 0.9% saline solution
pH was adjusted to 1 with HCl 0.1 N
All reagents used were analytical grade
Preparation and control
Sn colloid preparation was carried out with the following technique: a kit was heated (by autoclave or water bath) for preset times (15, 30, 60 or 90 min). Different final volumes were assayed with the addition of 0.9% saline solution (0, 0.5, 1.0 or 1.5 mL). Two tin kit formulations were tested: with or without the tensoactive agent (1-% w/w Tween 80®).
Labeling procedure and quality control
The 188Re were eluted from a 188W/188Re generator (MAP Technologies, Finland).
The 188Re-Sn colloid was labeled by the addition of 500 μCi (18.5 MBq) of 188ReO4 - to the kit formulation described before, then it was autoclaved for 1 h. pH was adjusted to 8.0 with a phosphate buffer 0.2 M.
The 188Re-S was labeled by the addition of 500 μCi (18.5 MBq) of 188ReO4 - to the kit formulation described previously; then it was heated at 100°C for 30 min. pH was adjusted to 8.0 with a phosphate buffer 0.2 M.
Radiochemical purity was determined by paper chromatography (Whatmann N°1) using 0.9% saline solution as the mobile phase. Radioactivity was measured with a Nal(Tl) solid scintillation counter of 3 × 3" (EG&G ORTEC Multichannel Analizer).
Physical characterization of the colloids
The physical characterization of Sn and S colloids was measured adding a similar volume of 0.9% saline solution to the generator eluate for each kit formulation.
The number, volume and area of the colloid particles were analyzed with a laser diffraction particle size analyzer (Particle Size Analyzer Coulter®).
Colloid particle size was also determined by membrane filtration, with serially connected filters of 1.2, 3 and 5 microns porous size (Sartorius® AG, cellulose nitrate filter).
The activity retained in each filter and filtrate was measured in a Capintec Radioisotope Calibrator (CRC-5R, calibration factor of 496).
In vitro and in vivo stability studies were performed for the Sn kit
In vitro stability studies
Two batches of the tin colloid kit with or without the tensoactive, kept at 2–8°C were studied for 60 days. At preset sampling times of 0, 15, 30, 45 and 60 days, the tin colloid was labeled, radiochemical purity was checked and characterization by laser diffraction and membrane filtration was done.
In vivo stability studies
Biodistribution in New Zealand adult rabbits (4-kg weight) were performed. The animals were sacrificed with an overdose of thiopental sodium after 48 hrs of intraarticular administration of 188Re-Sn colloid (500 μCi/mL, 18.5 MBq/mL). Articulation, liver, spleen, lungs, stomach, intestines, kidney, muscle, blood and urine samples were collected and radioactivity was measured in a NaI(Tl) scintillation counter (Ortec®), with a 3 × 3" crystal.
This study was carried out at three times: 0, 30 and 60 days after batch preparation of the tin kit.
Three batches of the tin kit were prepared at the same time, and physical parameters were determined as described above, immediately after preparation and seven days afterwards.
The New Zealand rabbits were anesthetized by intramuscular administration of 50 mg/kg ketamine and 10 mg/kg of xilazine. Scintigrafic images were acquired with a Shopy Camera DSX CP, with medium energy collimator, at 0, 24 and 48 hours after intraarticular administration of the radiopharmaceutical.
The particle distribution of Sn and S colloids was analyzed according to three parameters: number, volume and surface area of the particles. For this purpose particle size were grouped in three ranges (lower than 2 microns, between 2 to 10 microns, higher than 10 microns), as is shown in Figure 1. The incidence of heating procedure (room temperature, water bath temperature and autoclave) in colloid formation is also shown. The number of particles of the two colloids did not differ (Figure 1a). The Sn colloid showed a better particle distribution than the S colloid, when particle surface area or volumes of both preparations were considered. Figures 1(b) and 1(c).
Labeling procedure optimization
188Re-Sn colloid was obtained with a radiochemical purity higher than 90% after autoclaving for 30 min, and higher than 95% if heating was maintained for 1 hour (Figure 2). Since electrolytes might destabilize the colloid, the addition of a saline solution volume was evaluated. When the ratio (added volume/kit volume) was higher than two, the percentage of radiolabeled colloid was higher than 90%, as is shown figure 3.
In vitro stability studies
A three-dimensional plot representation (Figure 4) was chosen to show Sn colloid evolution immediately after preparation and 60 days afterwards (diameter on the x-axis, particle number on the y-axis and either surface area or volume on the z-axis). Colloid aging produces an increase in the volume and surface of the smaller particles, as could be appreciated when they were shown in the selected ranges.
Besides this, the stability of a kit that had already been prepared was followed for 24 hours, and no significant changes were evident during this interval.
The robustness of the product prepared in this manner was verified, showing minimal variation between 3 batches at t = 0. This behavior was maintained throughout the first week for all the batches.
Radioactivity vs. particle distribution
The 188Re-Sn colloid was analyzed by membrane filtration for 8 weeks after kit preparation and the distribution of the activity was plotted as a function of particle size grouped in four ranges (< 1.2 microns, 1.2 – 3 microns, 3 – 5 microns and > 5.0 microns), as shown in figure 5. It can be seen that more than 60% of the activity was found in particles bigger than 5 microns.
Particle size distribution was not affected by heating 30, 60 or 90 min as shown in figure 6.
Methodologies for physical characterization of colloids
As described above, two methodologies were used to characterize the physical parameters of colloids preparations: membrane filtration and laser diffraction. Figure 7 compares results for the same colloid formulation studied by the two techniques. A great difference can be seen between the results obtained by the two methodologies immediately after kit preparation between both methodologies. This observation was in agreement with the fact that tin colloid variations were significant only during the first week and were detected by laser diffraction methodology but not by membrane filtration methodology.
In vivo studies
Figure 8 shows selected organ or tissue activity distribution, after 48 hours of 188Re-Sn (with or without tensoactive addition) intraarticular administration to New Zealand rabbits.
The scintigraphic image evidenced relevant activity only in the knee, and negligible activity in the rest of the organism. (Figure 9).
The physical characteristics of the Sn and S colloids obtained were analyzed to select the formulation, which showed the best parameters.
It has been well established by other investigators that the radiopharmaceutical particle size must be small enough to be phagocyted by the superficial cells of the synovium but not so small as to facilitate a fast biological clearance from the articulation [12, 13] was taken into account.
Different optimal ranges of particle sizes considered as ideal for radiosynovectomy have been reported [4, 6, 7, 12, 14, 15]. Differences found in the literature are probably based on the use of different methodologies to measure particle size. Other parameters were considered in our study, such as total particle volume or the sum of different volume sizes grouped in the ranges of interest. In the same way, another criteria were colloid surface area in selected ranges.
As radioactivity was deposited as a function of volume or surface of the particles, methodologies that put this into evidence and analyzed further modifications of the formulation in the same way should enable to arrive to consistent conclusions. It was found that in the 2–10 microns range, the Sn colloid attained a greater number, volume and surface are of particles than those of the S colloid.
Nearly 95% of the S colloid volume belonged to those particles larger than 100 microns, in spite of the fact that these were a very small percentage of the whole preparation. On the other hand, 60% of the Sn colloid volume was composed of particles with size in the selected range, while only 5% of the volume of the S autoclaved colloid gave particles sizes in the same range.
Three-dimensional plot representation turned out to be an interesting tool to study valuable information about the behavior of colloids to study particle volume or surface area as a function of number, in a particular range.
The correlation of the two colloid characterization methodologies suggested that when a kit was evaluated by membrane filtration erroneous results might have been obtained, such as overestimation of particle percentage due to non-specific retention on the filter. This phenomenon was observed for those particles larger than 5 microns, immediately after kit preparation, where the electrical properties of the colloid were more significant. Besides that, only laser diffraction methodology provided a method to evaluate differences due to the aging of kit formulation during the first week after kit preparation and during the first 24 hours after similar conditions to those of labeling of tin colloid. This last observation made it possible to define a shelf life of 24 hours for the labeled colloid.
The effect of tensoactive addition was also studied (Tween 80®) in order to facilitate radiopharmaceutical administration. It was thought that this addition would not diminish colloid stability due to counteract particle coalition. It is known that small particles will show a gradual increase in size, a phenomenon that is called Ostwald maturation . Smaller particles have a greater solubility than larger ones of the same preparation, due to their higher surface area and free superficial energy. Spontaneous enlargement of colloidal dispersions due to aging, is accelerated by an increase in precipitate solubility and may be delayed by diminishing their solubility or by adding very small amounts of tensoactive agents that are absorbed on the surface of the particle. Taking this into account, Tween 80 was added to the formulation, but results were different to those described above because particle volume showed an increase after kit preparation.
The radiochemical purity of the 188Re-Sn colloid showed an increase after heating the colloid from thirty to sixty minutes. This fact implied a slow reaction, which required this time to reach the best value (95%). Activity distribution in the different ranges of particle size was not affected by heating time. Activity absorption on each particle is an unspecific process. Eighty percent of the activity was kept in those particles retained by the 5 microns filter – for heating time of 30, 60 or 90 min-, and these particles were a small amount of the total preparation. Ninety eight percent of particles, in number, had sizes below 3 microns and concentrated only about 10% of the whole activity. This fact confirmed to us that particle volume or surface area were the main parameters to be taken into account. Therefore particle size distribution did not correlate with activity data distribution.
More important changes in particle distribution were detected during the first week after kit preparation, this being the time needed for colloid stabilization. No further relevant changes were noted during the stability study so that eight weeks of shelf life could be safely proposed.
In vivo studies have shown that 48 hours post-administration knee retention was higher than 90%. One and three percent of activity was detected in the kidney and liver respectively, which can be attributed to the smallest particles (less than 1 micron); activities of urine samples were at background levels.
One of the most important characteristics of a radiopharmaceutical for synovectomy is to deliver a radiation dose in the target tissue, and if there is any leakage from the joint this should be insignificant. Good stability and low cost are also very important features.
The 188Re-Sn colloid fulfilled both objectives, which makes it an attractive radiotherapeutical agent for rheumatoid arthritis treatment in the knee. Forty-eight hours after administration, nearly 90% of the total radiation remained inside the knee joint.
The 188W/188Re generator, with a shelf life of six months, had a suitable performance for this clinical application.
The three-dimensional plot representation of colloid physical characteristics offered valuable information, both qualitative and quantitative, about colloid particle behavior. This was very important because particles smaller than 2 microns, numerically made up more than 90% of the whole preparation, but the activity remained adsorbed by the bigger ones, which could be retained and/or phagocyted inside the joint. Distribution by particle size was the least suitable characterization for detecting minor differences between the two preparations. If the membrane filtration method alone had been used for detecting activity distribution on colloid particles, wrong conclusions might have been reached. The laser diffraction method allowed us to observe changes in volume or surface area in colloid particles through time and to determine slight variations in these parameters.
Physical characterization by laser diffraction was proved to be a valuable tool for radiopharmaceutical colloid formulations.
Rosenthall L: Use of radiocolloids for intraarticular therapy for synovitis. In: Therapy in nuclear medicine. Edited by: Spencer RP. 1978, New York: Grune & Stratton, 147-242.
Harbert JC: Radiocolloid therapy in joint disease. In: Nuclear medicine therapy. Edited by: Harbert JC. 1987, New York: Thieme Medical, 169-186.
Doherty M: Potential rheumatologic applications of intra-articular radiocolloid therapy. Geriatric Medicine Today. 1984, 3: 31-42.
Davis MA, Chinol M: Radiopharmaceuticals for radiation synovectomy: evaluation of two yttrium-90 particulate agent. J Nucl Med. 1989, 30: 1047-1055.
Murray T, Erskine Hilditch T: Therapeutic applications of radiopharmaceuticals. In: Textbook of Radiopharmacy. Theory and Practice. Edited by: Charles B Sampson. 1999, Gordon and Breach Science Publishers, 380-3
Wang SJ, Lin WY, Hsieh BT, Shen LH, Tsai ZT, Ting G, Knapp FF: Rhenium-188 sulphur colloid as a radiation synovectomy agent. Eur J Nucl Med. 1995, 22 (6): 505-7.
Venkatesan P, Shortkroff S, Zalutsky MR, Sledge CB: Rhenium heptasulfide: a potential carrier system for radiation synovectomy. Nucl Med Biol. 1990, 4: 293-357.
Johnson LS, Yanch JC, Shortkoff CL, Barnes AI, Sledge CB: Beta-particle dosimetry in radiation synovectomy. Eur J Nucl Med. 1995, 22 (9): 977-988.
Kamioki H, Mirzadeh S, Lambrecht RM, Knapp FF, Dadachova K: 188W/188 Re generator for biomedical applications. Radiochimica Acta. 1994, 65: 39-46.
Knapp FF, Mirzadeh S, Beets AL, O'Doherty M, Blower PJ, Verdera ES, Gaudiano JP, Kropp J, Guhlke H, Palmedo H, Biersack HJ: Reactor-produced radioisotopes from ORNL for bone pain palliation. Appl Radiat Isot. 1998, 49: 309-315. 10.1016/S0969-8043(97)00043-2.
Jeong JM, Lee YJ, Kim YJ, Chang YS, Lee DS, Chung JK, Song YW, Lee MC: Preparation of rhenium-188-tin colloid as a radiation synovectomy agent and comparison with rhenium-188-sulfur colloid. Appl Rad Isotopes. 2000, 52: 851-855. 10.1016/S0969-8043(99)00131-1.
Shortkroff S, Sledge CB: Radiation synovectomy. In: Principles of Nuclear Medicine. Edited by: Wagner HN Jr, Szabo Z, Buchanan JW. 1995, WB Saunders Co. Philadelphia, 1021-1028. 2
Noble J, Jones AG, Davies MA, Sledge CB, Kramer RI, Livni E: Leakage of radioactive practice system from synovial joint studied with a gamma camera; its application to radiation synovectomy. J Bone Joint Surg [Am]. 1983, 65: 381-389.
Chinol M, Vallabhajosula S, Goldsmith S, Klein M, Deutsch K, Chinen L, Brodack J, Deutsch E, Watson B, Tofe A: Chemistry and biological behaviour of Samarium-153 and Rhenium-186 labeled hydroxyapatite particles: potential radiopharmaceuticals for radiation synovectomy. J Nucl Med. 1993, 34 (9): 1536-1542.
Clunie G, Lui D, Edwards J, Ell P: Samarium-153 particulate hydroxyapatite radiation synovectomy: biodistribution data for chronic knee synovitis. J Nucl Med. 1995, 36: 51-57.
Schott H: Dispersiones coloidales. In Remington: Ciencia y Práctica de la Farmacia. Edited by: Editado por Alfonso Genaro Editores. 1997, Médica Panamericana, 366-404. 19
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2385/2/1/prepub
The authors wish to thank PEDECIBA Química for its financial support.
MCU participated in the design of the radiopharmaceutical, carried out the pharmaceutical experiments and drafted the manuscript.
ES planned the study and performed its coordination. He also drafted the manuscript.
AM performed the Coulter Analizer determinations.
MF performed the experimental animal studies.
AP carried out the scintigraphic studies.
JG responsible for the scintigraphic studies.
All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Ures, M.C., Savio, E., Malanga, A. et al. Physico-chemical characterisation and biological evaluation of 188-Rhenium colloids for radiosynovectomy. BMC Med Phys 2, 1 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2385-2-1
- Radiochemical Purity
- Laser Diffraction
- Intraarticular Injection
- Laser Diffraction Particle Size Analyzer
- Characterization Methodology